Hailee Steinfeld has always captivated audiences, but her latest role in Sinners has taken things to a whole new level. Starring opposite Michael B. Jordan—who delivers a knockout double act as twin brothers Smoke and Stack—Hailee’s character Mary shares such fiery chemistry with both roles that fans can’t help but raise eyebrows at her off-screen engagement to Buffalo Bills star Josh Allen.
Steinfeld and Allen, who announced their engagement in late 2024, had until recently been the very definition of couple goals. She’s been glowing in interviews, gushing about Allen’s warmth and how deeply she’s fallen in love with the city of Buffalo. But ever since Sinners premiered, a different kind of buzz has taken over social media.
“Josh Is Gonna Be SICK” — The Internet Reacts
From X (formerly Twitter) to TikTok, fans are in a frenzy. One user summed up the vibe perfectly: “The chemistry is insane… Josh is gonna be SICK.” Another took the speculation further, joking, “If I was Josh Allen, I would have called off the wedding.”
Though most comments are delivered with a wink, the fan energy surrounding Hailee and Michael’s electric onscreen connection is undeniable. One even wrote, “I love Josh Allen with all my heart, but if Hailee Steinfeld starts dating Michael B. Jordan, honestly not gonna get mad.”
With Sinners topping streaming charts and critics praising Jordan’s magnetic performance, the line between screen fantasy and real-life romance seems to be delightfully blurred—for audiences, at least.
Buffalo Still Has Her Heart
Despite the noise, Steinfeld has remained gracious and grounded. During a recent appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, she reaffirmed her affection for the city of Buffalo and, by extension, Allen himself. “I have been given a very warm welcome,” she said. “The people are incredible. It’s such a wonderful, wonderful place. I love it so much.”
While Hollywood fans may be rooting for a cinematic love triangle, Steinfeld’s real-life romance appears unshaken. But that hasn't stopped the memes, jokes, and even fantasy league-style matchups. One user hilariously proposed a solution: “Only reasonable way for Michael B. Jordan and Josh Allen to settle this is for Michael to spend a season with the Panthers and Josh to star as the next Black Panther.”
Wedding Bells or Plot Twists?
For now, it seems the only thing hotter than Steinfeld’s career is the spotlight following her every move. Whether it's wedding bells in Buffalo or fan-fueled rom-com daydreams, Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen are giving both sports and cinema lovers a storyline they can’t stop watching.
And as Sinners continues to sizzle, one thing’s for sure: in the game of love, art, and celebrity, the audience always wants more drama—even if it’s just on the silver screen.
Steinfeld and Allen, who announced their engagement in late 2024, had until recently been the very definition of couple goals. She’s been glowing in interviews, gushing about Allen’s warmth and how deeply she’s fallen in love with the city of Buffalo. But ever since Sinners premiered, a different kind of buzz has taken over social media.
“Josh Is Gonna Be SICK” — The Internet Reacts
From X (formerly Twitter) to TikTok, fans are in a frenzy. One user summed up the vibe perfectly: “The chemistry is insane… Josh is gonna be SICK.” Another took the speculation further, joking, “If I was Josh Allen, I would have called off the wedding.”
Just watched “Sinners” with Michael B. Jordan and Hailee Steinfeld. NGL if I was Josh Allen I would have called off the wedding😅
— Caleb Williams Fan Club (@CalebFC18) April 22, 2025
Though most comments are delivered with a wink, the fan energy surrounding Hailee and Michael’s electric onscreen connection is undeniable. One even wrote, “I love Josh Allen with all my heart, but if Hailee Steinfeld starts dating Michael B. Jordan, honestly not gonna get mad.”
With Sinners topping streaming charts and critics praising Jordan’s magnetic performance, the line between screen fantasy and real-life romance seems to be delightfully blurred—for audiences, at least.
Josh Allen says his fiancé Hailee Steinfeld was excellent in her new movie #Sinners
— Culture Crave 🍿 (@CultureCrave) April 24, 2025
“It was a different world—a very cool experience ... It’s a fantastic movie; so go watch it” pic.twitter.com/ZfDw4ZLPRt
Buffalo Still Has Her Heart
Despite the noise, Steinfeld has remained gracious and grounded. During a recent appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, she reaffirmed her affection for the city of Buffalo and, by extension, Allen himself. “I have been given a very warm welcome,” she said. “The people are incredible. It’s such a wonderful, wonderful place. I love it so much.”
While Hollywood fans may be rooting for a cinematic love triangle, Steinfeld’s real-life romance appears unshaken. But that hasn't stopped the memes, jokes, and even fantasy league-style matchups. One user hilariously proposed a solution: “Only reasonable way for Michael B. Jordan and Josh Allen to settle this is for Michael to spend a season with the Panthers and Josh to star as the next Black Panther.”
a simple google search would show you that Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen were together before Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce started dating 😭. They were like this during early stages of their relationship too https://t.co/1LOTVc1VHX pic.twitter.com/amyyf8U0Gr
— clueified (@clueified) March 7, 2024
Wedding Bells or Plot Twists?
For now, it seems the only thing hotter than Steinfeld’s career is the spotlight following her every move. Whether it's wedding bells in Buffalo or fan-fueled rom-com daydreams, Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen are giving both sports and cinema lovers a storyline they can’t stop watching.
And as Sinners continues to sizzle, one thing’s for sure: in the game of love, art, and celebrity, the audience always wants more drama—even if it’s just on the silver screen.
You may also like
AIIMS Bhubaneswar launches Robotic Knee Replacement facility
After Arijit, Shreya Ghoshal cancels her concert in the light of Pahalgam attack
George Russell admission is music to Red Bull ears as Verstappen handed cause for concern
TfL issued warning after drunk woman lay dead in Tube tunnel for two days
Formula E's next big challenge as McLaren quit series after three seasons
